Critics Divided Over Superman RebootMan of Steel's been in theaters for a week now, and the conversations about the strengths and weaknesses of the Superman reboot are heating up. I've been reading reviews (and the comments on the reviews) from all over the web, and it's amazing how divided people are about the movie.
One thing's for sure, though, despite some less-than-stellar reviews, the box office results don't lie - audiences love Man of Steel. The movie's an incredible success at the box office, setting a record for the biggest ever opening in the month of June.
I thought it would be fun to collect some of the reviews from around the internetz and do a quick comparison of the different opinions. It's interesting to see the different reactions people have toward Man of Steel, but before you check out the reviews, I have a favor to ask.
If you have a Google+ account, how about adding Capes on Film to your Circles, so you can stay in touch.
Now, on to those reviews -The Problem(s) with Man of Steel - by Kelly Thompson (comicbookresources.com)
Thompson lays out in detail why MoS was a complete failure, as not only a superhero movie, but as a movie in general. She does point out a few positive points about MoS, such as the character of Faora Ul, and Henry Cavill's and Amy Adams' performances. One of her biggest complaints about the film is the overall tone -
"...Man of Steel takes itself so seriously it actually becomes impossible to take it seriously."
|Michael Shannon as General Zod|
Waid is the reknowned writer of critically acclaimed Superman comic book stories, such as "Birthright". To put it bluntly, Waid hated MoS. He especially despised the way Superman didn't really seem to care about protecting people. The scene he points to as an example of Supe's disregard of human life is when the Kryptonian ship is destroying Metropolis and Kal-El is on the other side of the world battling the other ship, while
"...thousands of innocents per second are dying gruesomely on his watch."
I Loved Man of Steel and I Hated Man of Steel - Nicole Wakelin (totalfangirl.com)
Wakelin loved Henry Cavill's performance and thought he owned the role from the start, but she hated the climactic battle scene.
"Once Superman has been revealed, the super-battles start and they never end."
Man of Steel - Another Movie Review - C.C. Ekeke (geektyrant.com)
Overall, this is a very positive review, but like many others it points out the huge collateral damage that occurred in the Battle of Metropolis - and Supe's apparent disregard for the thousands of casualties. Ekeke gives high marks for the opening scene on Krypton and he loved the political intrigue between Zod and Jor-El. Unlike many reviewers, he thought the way Supes dealt with Zod at the end made sense.
"...he had to make a very real choice between the lives of civilians and the last of his kind."
Part Man, Part God, All Hunk - Manohla Dargis (newyorktimes.com)
Dargis praises the performances of Cavill and the rest of the cast, especially Michael Shannon as Zod. She also praises the first 100 minutes of the film, saying Snyder is "...in control of his material..." and his use of flashbacks is "...fluid and apt." Dargis also gives high marks to the underlying story of Kal-El as an outsider -
"...it's possible to remain hooked on the resonant origin story that wends through 'Man of Steel' - that of the immigrant."